160 West 54th Street
New York, NY 10019

(212) 471-4860

MENU

  • Dinner
  • Bar
  • Lunch
  • Breakfast
  • Brunch
  • Dessert
  • Kids Menu

Basket of Fries - $7
Authentic Curried Ketchup

Basket of Onion Rings - $7 
Authentic Curried Ketchup

Buffalo Chicken Wings - $12
Mild or Hot, Blue Cheese Dressing

Mozzarella Sticks - $10
Basil Tomato Sauce

Loaded Potato Skins - $12
Sour Cream, Bacon, Jalapeños & Cheddar Cheese

Buffalo Chicken Dip - $12
Crispy Corn Tortilla Chips

Chicken Tenders - $12
Honey Mustard Sauce & Fries

Margherita Pizza - $12/$14   

Pepperoni Pizza - $13/$15


Chili Con Carne - $13
Topped with Blended Irish Cheddar & Monterrey Jack Cheese, served with Crispy Tortilla Chips.

Smoked Chicken Chipotle Quesadilla - $13
Black Beans, Monterey Jack Cheese, Pico de Gallo, Sour Cream & Guacamole.

Trio of Pulled Pork Tacos - $13
Guacamole, Poblano Tomato Salsa & Sour Cream

BBQ Chicken Ribs - $15
Jameson Broccoli Slaw & Fries

Nachos Grande - $15
Crispy Corn Tortilla Chips, Melted Cheddar & Jack Cheese, Pico de Gallo, Black Olives, Jalapeños, Sour Cream, Guacamole & Chili

Maryland Crab Cake - $16
Crab Salad, Fresh Jumbo Lump Crab Cake with Mango Corn Salsa & Chipotle Mayo

Caprese Salad - $14

Fresh Mozzarella, Tomato $ Basil, Drizzled in Basil Olive Oil & Sweet Balsamic Reduction.

Old Castle Beef Sliders - $15
Guinness Onions, Cheddar Cheese & Chipotle Sauce

Crispy Calamari - $16
Fra Diavolo Tomato Sauce

Oldcastle Sampler - $20
Chicken Tenders, Buffalo Chicken Wings, Potato Skins & Mozzarella Sticks

Soup Du Jour - $8

French Onion Soup - $8

Oldcastle House Salad - $11
Iceberg Lettuce, Carrots, Escarole, White Cabbage, Tomatoes, Cucumbers & Red Onions, tossed in a Honey Mustard Dressing.
*Add Chicken $4 / Shrimp $7 / Pat la Frieda’s Steak $9

Southwest Salad - $14
House Salad, Black Beans, Corn, Cheddar Cheese & Chili Lime Tortillas, tossed in a Chipotle Ranch Dressing.
*Add Chicken $4 / Shrimp $7 / Pat la Frieda’s Steak $9


Walnut Crusted Chicken Breast Salad - $17
Baby Spinach, Pineapple Poached Pears, Cherry Tomatoes, Crispy Onions & Maytag Blue Cheese, tossed in a Strawberry Vinaigrette Dressing.

Cedar Grilled Chicken Caesar - $18
Crisp Romaine Lettuce, Creamy Parmesan, Herb Croutons & Grated Grana Padano.


Oldcastle Fettucine Alfredo - $18
Mushrooms, Peas, Sun-dried Tomatoes, tossed in a Cream Sauce with Shaved Parmesan Cheese
*Add Chicken $4 / Shrimp $7

Classic Penne Ala Vodka - $18
Garlic & Prosciutto, tossed in an Absolute Vodka Sauce
*Add Chicken $4 / Shrimp $7

Shepperd’s Pie - $20
Ground Sirloin, Peas, Carrots, Onions & Celery, topped with Mashed Potatoes.

Traditional Fish & Chips - $19
Battered Atlantic Cod, Steak Cut Fries & Caper Style Tartar.

Chicken Pot Pie - $20
Creamy Chicken Vegetable Stew, topped with a Crisp Puff Pastry.

Bangers, Beans & Mash - $20
Irish Sausage over Mashed Potatoes, topped with Baked Beans, Caramelized Onions & Mushroom Gravy.

Hunter Chicken Breast - $21
Mushrooms, Scallions, Tomatoes, Tarragon Pan Gravy, Mashed Potatoes & Seasonal Vegetables.

McDonnell’s Shrimp Curry - $25
Peppers, Onions & Diced Fresh Pineapple, tossed in a Original Curry Sauce, served with Cheddar Fries.

Grilled Norwegian Atlantic Salmon Filet - $26
Lime Garlic Sauce, Sauteed Spinach & Potato Pancakes.
Steaks
With your choice of sauces: 
Jameson BBQ / Red Wine Mushrooms / Blue Cheese & Truffle Oil Butter / Three Mustards Gaelic Sauce

10 oz. Cajun Spiced Hanger Steak - $29
Served with Honey Glazed Vegetables & Fries. 

14 oz.  Rib Eye Steak  - $34
Served with Mashed Potatoes & Roasted Asparagus.

8 oz. Filet Mignon - $39
Served with Potato Cakes & Creamed Spinach.


Burgers - $18
Gourmet Special Blend (Short Rib, Brisket & Chuck), on a Toasted Brioche Bun, served with French Fries.

Oldcastle Burger
Cheddar Cheese, Applewood Smoked Bacon, Caramelized Onions & Fine Herbs Mushrooms.

Times Square Burger
Aged Blue Cheese, Original Irish Bacon & Sunny Side Up Egg.

Dublin City Burger
White Cheddar Cheese, Pork Sausage, Secret Sauce.

California Veggie Burger
Pepper Jack Cheese & Roasted Tomato, on a Whole Wheat Bun.


All served with French Fries.

Smoked House Pastrami - $17
Thinly Sliced Pastrami, Caramelized Red Onions, Gruyere Cheese, Colman’s Mustard & Sliced Pickles, on Sourdough Bread.

Crispy Chicken Ranch Wrap - $17
Chicken, Bacon, Lettuce, Tomato, Bell Peppers, Red Onions & Buttermilk Ranch Dressing, wrapped in a Whole Wheat Tortilla.

Paddy Reilly’s Corned Beef Sandwich - $17
Guinness Deli Mustard & Aged Swiss Cheese, on Rye Toast.

Pesto Chicken Sandwich - $17
Grilled Chicken Breast with Tomato, Bacon, Mozzarella Cheese & Pesto Sauce on Sourdough Bread.

18% service charge will be added to parties of six or more

160 West 54th Street – New York, NY – 10019 – Phone – 212.471.4860
www.Oldcastlepub.com

Basket of Fries - $7
Authentic Curried Ketchup

Basket of Onion Rings - $7
Authentic Curried Ketchup

Buffalo Chicken Wings - $12
Mild or Hot, Blue Cheese Dressing

Mozzarella Sticks - $10
Basil Tomato Sauce

Loaded Potato Skins - $12
Sour Cream, Bacon, Jalapeños & Cheddar Cheese

Buffalo Chicken Dip - $12
Crispy Corn Tortilla Chips

Smoked Chicken Chipotle Quesadilla - $13
Black Beans, Monterey Jack Cheese, Pico de Gallo, Sour Cream & Guacamole

Chicken Tenders - $12
Honey Mustard Sauce

Margherita Pizza (10”/12”) - $12/$14

Pepperoni Pizza (10”/12”) - $13/$15

Trio of Pulled Pork Tacos - $13
Guacamole, Poblano Tomato Salsa & Sour Cream

BBQ Chicken Ribs - $15
Jameson Broccoli Slaw & Fries

Nachos Grande - $15
Crispy Corn Tortilla Chips, Melted Cheddar & Jack Cheese, Pico de Gallo, Black Olives, Jalapeños, Sour Cream, Guacamole & Chili

Old Castle Beef Sliders - $15
Guinness Onions, Cheddar Cheese & Chipotle Sauce

Crispy Calamari- $16
Fra Diavolo Tomato Sauce

Castle Beef Burger - $18
Cheddar Cheese, Bacon, Caramelized Onions, Mushrooms & Fries

Fish & Chips - $19

Old Castle Sampler - $20
Chicken Tenders, Buffalo Chicken Wings, Potato Skins & Mozzarella Sticks

$6 Select Appetizers
Monday-Friday 5PM-7PM
Nachos
6” Pizza
Wings
Plain or Cheddar Fries

BV Century Cellars Cabernet

8

29

Altos Del Plata Cabernet

8

33

Once Upon A Vine Pinot Noir

9

31

Altos Del Plata Malbec

9

33

BV Costal Estates Merlot

8

29

 

 

BV Century Cellars Chardonnay

8

29

Altos Del Plata Chardonnay

9

31

BV Costal Estates Riesling

8

29

Stellina di Notte Pinot Grigio

8

29

New Harbor Sauvignon Blanc

9

31

Blossom Hill White Zinfandel

9

 

 

Wycliff Brut Champagne

8

34

Stellina di Notte Prosecco

 10

36

Dom Perignon

 

350

Heineken

Magners

Heineken Light 

Coors Light

Corona

Coors N/A

Corona Light

Reed's Ginger

Budweiser

Miller Light

Bud Light

Michelob Ultra

Amstel Light

Modelo

Angry Orchard

Heineken 

Bass Ale

Oldcastle Brew

Blue Moon

Sam Adams

Brooklyn Lager

Sam Seasonal

Budweiser

Smithwicks

Bud Light 

Stella Artois

Coney Island 

Coney Island IPA

 

Basket of Fries - $7
Authentic Curried Ketchup

Basket of Onion Rings - $7
Authentic Curried Ketchup

Buffalo Chicken Wings - $12
Mild or Hot, Blue Cheese Dressing

Mozzarella Sticks - $10
Basil Tomato Sauce

Loaded Potato Skins - $12
Sour Cream, Bacon, Jalapeños & Cheddar Cheese

Buffalo Chicken Dip - $12
Crispy Corn Tortilla Chips

Chicken Tenders - $12
Honey Mustard Sauce & Fries

Chili Con Carne - $13
Topped with Blended Irish Cheddar & Monterey Jack Cheese, served with Crispy Tortilla Chips.

Smoked Chicken Chipotle Quesadilla - $13
Black Beans, Monterey Jack Cheese, Pico de Gallo, Sour Cream & Guacamole.

Trio of Pulled Pork Tacos - $13
Guacamole, Poblano Tomato Salsa & Sour Cream

BBQ Chicken Ribs - $15
Jameson Broccoli Slaw & Fries

Nachos Grande - $15
Crispy Corn Tortilla Chips, Melted Cheddar & Jack Cheese, Pico de Gallo, Black Olives, Jalapeños, Sour Cream, Guacamole & Chili

Maryland Crab Cake - $14
Fresh Jumbo Lump Crab Cake with Mango Corn Salsa & Chipotle Mayo

Caprese Salad - $12
Fresh Mozzarella, Tomato & Basil, Drizzled in a Basil Olive Oil & Sweet Balsamic Reduction

Old Castle Beef Sliders - $15

Guinness Onions, Cheddar Cheese & Chipotle Sauce

Crispy Calamari - $16
Fra Diavolo Tomato Sauce

Oldcastle Sampler - $20
Chicken Tenders, Buffalo Chicken Wings, Potato Skins & Mozzarella Sticks

Soup Du Jour - $8

French Onion Soup - $8

Oldcastle House Salad - $10
Iceberg Lettuce, Carrots, Escarole, White Cabbage, Tomatoes, Cucumbers & Red Onions, 
tossed in a Honey Mustard Dressing.
*Add Chicken $4 / Shrimp $7 / Pat la Frieda’s Steak $9

Southwest Salad - $13
House Salad, Black Beans, Corn, Cheddar Cheese & Chili Lime Tortillas, 
tossed in a Chipotle Ranch Dressing.
*Add Chicken $4 / Shrimp $7 / Pat la Frieda’s Steak $9

Walnut Crusted Chicken Breast Salad - $16
Baby Spinach, Pineapple Poached Pears, Cherry Tomatoes, Crispy Onions & Maytag Blue 
Cheese, tossed in a Strawberry Vinaigrette Dressing.

Cedar Grilled Chicken Caesar - $17
Crisp Romaine Lettuce, Creamy Parmesan, Herb Croutons & Grated Grana Padano.


All Sandwiches Are With  French Fries
Smoked House Pastrami - $16
Thinly Sliced Pastrami, Caramelized Red Onions, Gruyere Cheese, Coleman's Mustard & Sliced Pickles, on Sourdough Bread.

Chicken Cordon Bleu Sliders - $16
Virginia Ham, Swiss Cheese & Gravy, on Mini Brioche Buns.

Crispy Chicken Ranch Wrap - $16
Chicken, Bacon, Lettuce, Tomato, Bell Peppers, Red Onions & Buttermilk Ranch Dressing, wrapped in a Whole Wheat Tortilla.

Paddy Reilly’s Corned Beef Sandwich - $16
Guinness Deli Mustard & Aged Swiss Cheese, on Rye Toast.

Pesto Chicken Sandwich - $16
Grilled Chicken Breast with Tomato, Bacon, Mozzarella Cheese & Pesto Sauce on Sourdough Bread

Burgers - $18
Gourmet Special Blend (Short Rib, Brisket & Chuck), on a Toasted Brioche Bun, served with French Fries.

Oldcastle Burger
Cheddar Cheese, Applewood Smoked Bacon, Caramelized Onions & Fine Herbs Mushrooms.
Times Square Burger
Aged Blue Cheese, Original Irish Bacon & Sunny Side Up Egg.
Dublin City Burger
White Cheddar Cheese, Pork Sausage, Secret Sauce.
California Veggie Burger
Pepper Jack Cheese & Roasted Tomato on a Whole Wheat Bun


Margherita - $12/$14

Pepperoni - $13/$15

Oldcastle Fettucine Alfredo - $16 (*Add Chicken $4 / Shrimp $7)
Mushrooms, Peas, Sun-dried Tomatoes, tossed in a Cream Sauce with Shaved Parmesan Cheese

Classic Penne Ala Vodka - $16 (*Add Chicken $4 / Shrimp $7)
Garlic & Prosciutto, tossed in an Absolut Vodka Sauce

Chicken Pot Pie - $19
Creamy Chicken Vegetable Stew, topped with a Crisp Puff Pastry.

Hunter Chicken Breast - $19
Mushrooms, Scallions, Tomatoes, Tarragon Pan Gravy, Mashed Potatoes & Seasonal Vegetables.

Shepperd’s Pie - $19
Ground Sirloin, Peas, Carrots, Onions & Celery, topped with Mashed Potatoes.

Traditional Fish & Chips - $18
Battered Atlantic Cod, Steak Cut Fries & Caper Style Tartar.

Bangers, Beans & Mash - $20
Irish Sausage over Mashed Potatoes, topped with Baked Beans, Caramelized Onions & Mushroom Gravy.

McDonnell’s Shrimp Curry - $22
Peppers, Onions & Diced Fresh Pineapple, tossed in a Original Curry Sauce, served with Cheddar Fries.

Grilled Norwegian Atlantic Salmon Filet - $23
Lime Garlic Sauce, Sauteed Spinach & Potato Pancakes.

8 oz. Filet Mignon - $39
Served with Potato Cake and Creamed Spinach

18% service charge will be added to parties of six or more

160 West 54th Street – New York, NY – 10019 – Phone – 212.471.4860
www.Oldcastlepub.com


Monday - Friday 8am – 12pm 
Full Lunch & Breakfast Menu Also Available Upon Request

Oatmeal - $8
With your choice of Bananas, Raisins, Mixed Berries or Diced Apples, Brown Sugar or Honey.

Castle Sandwich - $13
Two Scrambled Eggs topped with Bacon & Cheese, served on a Toasted Brioche Bun with Home Fries.

Country Omelet - $13
Three Eggs stuffed with Onions, Peppers, Ham & American Cheese, served with Home Fries & Toast.

All American Breakfast - $15
Two Eggs cooked any style, with your choice of Bacon or Sausage, served with Home Fries & Toast.

French Toast - $13
Light & Fluffy, topped with Sliced Bananas & Peanut Butter Drizzle, served with Maple Syrup.

Pancake Stack - $14
Three Pancakes with your choice of Bacon or Sausage, served with Maple Syrup.

Texas Toast Grilled Cheese - $14
With Irish Bacon, American Cheese & Grilled Tomato, served with Home Fries.

Three Cheese Omelet - $13
Three Eggs filled with American, Cheddar & Mozzarella Cheese, Spinach & Mushrooms, served with Home Fries & Toast.

Belgium Waffle - $14
Served with Bacon or Sausage, Maple Syrup, Fresh Fruit, topped with Homemade Whipped Cream.

Eggs Florentine - $13
Garlic Spinach with Two Poached Eggs, topped with Hollandaise Sauce on an English Muffin, served with Home Fries.

Classic Irish Breakfast - $17
Two Eggs any style, Irish Sausage, Irish Bacon, Black & White Pudding, Grilled Tomato, Beans & Toast.

Oldcastle Deluxe Breakfast - $17
Two Eggs any style, with your choice of Bacon or Sausage, served with Pancakes & Home Fries.

12 oz. Pat la Frieda’s N.Y. Steak & Eggs - $25 
Two Eggs any style, served with Home Fries & Toast.

Sides
American Bacon - $4
Irish Bacon - $5
Toast - $3
Home Fries - $4
Irish Sausage - $5
Beans - $5
Fresh Fruit - $6/$11 
(Small/Large)
Egg White Substitution - $3

Additional charges for substitutions or additions.


Saturday & Sunday 8am – 4pm 
Full Lunch & Breakfast Menu Also Available Upon Request

Classic Irish Breakfast 
Two Eggs any style, Irish Sausage, Irish Bacon, Black & White Pudding, Grilled Tomato, Beans & Toast.

Eggs Benedict Irish Style
Irish Bacon with Two Poached Eggs, topped with Hollandaise Sauce on an English Muffin, served with Home Fries.

Eggs Florentine
Garlic Spinach with Two Poached Eggs, topped with Hollandaise Sauce on an English Muffin, served with Home Fries.

Country Omelet 
Three Eggs stuffed with Onions, Peppers, Ham & American Cheese, served with Home Fries & Toast.

Three Cheese Omelet 
Three Eggs filled with American, Cheddar & Mozzarella Cheese, Spinach & Mushrooms, served with Home Fries & Toast.

All American Breakfast
Two Eggs cooked any style, with your choice of Bacon or Sausage, served with Home Fries & Toast.

French Toast 
Light & Fluffy, topped with Sliced Bananas & Peanut Butter Drizzle, served with Maple Syrup.

Belgium Waffle 
With your choice of Bacon or Sausage, served with Maple Syrup, Fresh Fruit, topped with Homemade Whipped Cream.

Pancake Stack 
Three Pancakes with your choice of Bacon or Sausage, served with Maple Syrup.

Chicken Cobb Salad
House Salad, Tomato, Onions, Avocado, Boiled Egg & Bacon, tossed in a Blue Cheese Dressing.

Crispy Buffalo Chicken Wrap
Crispy Chicken marinated in Buffalo Sauce, with Lettuce, Tomato & Blue Cheese Dressing on a Whole Wheat Wrap, served with French Fries.

Texas Toast BLT Sandwich
American Bacon, Lettuce & Tomato with Tarragon Mayo, served with Home Fries.

Homemade Veggie Burger
On a Whole Wheat Bun, served with a side Salad & your choice of Dressing.

Pat la Frieda’s Beef Burger
American Cheese, Smoked Bacon & Fried Egg, on a Brioche Bun with Home Fries.

12 oz. Pat la Frieda’s N.Y. Steak & Eggs
Two Eggs any style, served with Home Fries & Toast.

$16. Prix-Fixe Served with a Complimentary Bloody Mary, Mimosa, Screwdriver* OR  Tea , Coffee,  Juice
Additional charges for substitutions or additions.

* Must be 21 years of age or older, Proof of age is required


Desserts 
Selection of Ice Cream - $7
 

Vanilla, Chocolate, or Strawberry

Chocolate Mousse Cake - $8 
With Fresh Whipped Cream

Baileys Irish Cream Cheesecake - $8 
With Fresh Whipped Cream

Chocolate Chip Brownie - $8
With Vanilla Ice Cream

Classic Apple Pie - $8
With Vanilla Ice Cream


After Dinner Drinks 
Irish Coffee

Nutty Irishman
Mexican Coffee
Irish Mist
Frangelico
Grand Marnier
Disaronno Amaretto
Sambuca Black/White


Single Malt Scotch and Whiskey
Bowmore 12yr
Glenfiddich 12yr
Glenmorangie
Talisker 10yr
Glenlivet 12yr/18yr
MaCallan 12yr/18yr
Lagavulin 16yr
Oban 14yr
Johnnie Walker Select Cask
Johnnie Walker Green Label
Johnnie Walker Blue Label
Glendalough
Glendalough 7yr
Jameson 12yr/18yr



Bourbon and Cognac 
Bulliet Bourbon
Knob Creek
Woodford Reserve
Bakers
Basil Hayden
Bookers
Hennessy
Hennessy VSOP

Kids Menu - $9
(Includes Drink & Dessert)

Mac & Cheese
Mozzarella Sticks
Grilled Cheese & Fries
Chicken Fingers & Fries
Mini Beef Burger & Fries
Penne with Butter or Marinara 
Chicken Breast, Mash & Veggies

Soda
Milk/Chocolate Milk/7up/Coke/Diet Coke/Ginger Ale/Shirley Temple

Juice
Apple/Pineapple/Orange/Cranberry/Grapefruit

Dessert
Vanilla/Strawberry/Chocolate Ice Cream or Bowl of Fresh Fruit